The Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) has ruled that differences in the pay scales applicable to Lieutenant Generals cannot, by themselves, justify a disparity in salaries between senior and junior officers holding the same military rank and performing the same duties. The Tribunal has directed the Army to step up the pay of a retired Lieutenant General after finding that he had drawn a lower salary than a junior officer despite being placed in the higher Higher Administrative Grade-Plus (HAG-Plus) scale.
In its order dated November 13, a Bench comprising Justice Anu Malhotra and Administrative Member Rasika Chaube observed that the peculiar arrangement under which Lieutenant Generals are placed in three different pay scales according to seniority cannot prejudice the principle of equal pay for officers holding the same rank. The Tribunal rejected an interpretation that recognised the officers as belonging to the same military rank for service, appointments and duties but treated them as incomparable when addressing an established pay anomaly.
The applicant was commissioned into the Corps of Signals in December 1977 and retired from service in July 2016. Following his promotion to the rank of Lieutenant General in October 2012, he was initially placed in the Higher Administrative Grade (HAG), with a monthly pay of ₹75,000. In January 2014, he was upgraded to the HAG-Plus scale, following which his pay was revised to ₹80,000.
After the implementation of the Seventh Central Pay Commission recommendations with effect from January 1, 2016, his pay was fixed at ₹2,17,900. However, the officer subsequently noticed that a junior from the same Corps, who was promoted to Lieutenant General in July 2016, had his pay fixed at ₹2,24,100 in the HAG scale. As a result, the senior officer continued to draw a lower salary despite his seniority and placement in the higher HAG-Plus grade.
The applicant challenged the pay fixation, arguing that it was contrary to Rule 7 of the Army Officers Pay Rules, 2017. His counsel, retired Colonel Indra Sen Singh, submitted that the provision required the pay of a senior officer to be stepped up to the level of a junior when the latter, promoted on or after January 1, 2016, drew higher pay than a senior promoted before that date.
The officer’s counsel further argued that the anomaly had affected not only his salary during service but also his retirement benefits. His pension was fixed on the basis of the lower pay of ₹2,17,900, resulting in a consequential impact on his pensionary entitlements. The applicant contended that the disparity was arbitrary and discriminatory and violated the constitutional guarantee of equality as well as the principle of equal pay for equal work.
The Army opposed the application, maintaining that HAG and HAG-Plus were two distinct pay levels and were treated separately for the purposes of pay fixation and promotion. According to the Army, the applicant had been placed in HAG-Plus, while his junior was in HAG, meaning that the two officers did not occupy identical pay levels. It argued that the conditions prescribed under Rule 7 for stepping up pay were therefore not fulfilled.
The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts also declined the request, stating that the statutory conditions for stepping up pay had not been met. The authorities relied on the definitions of “Pay Matrix” and “Existing Pay Band and Grade Pay” under the relevant rules, which identify HAG as Level 15 and HAG-Plus as Level 16. The government counsel further submitted that there was no direct recruitment to either grade and that the placement of one-third of Lieutenant Generals in HAG-Plus on the basis of seniority did not remove the statutory distinction between the two pay levels.
The Tribunal, however, examined the circumstances of the pay anomaly and the nature of the two grades. It noted that the applicant was drawing ₹2,17,900 in January 2016, while his junior was then drawing ₹2,11,800 as a Major General. Following the junior officer’s promotion to Lieutenant General in July 2016, his pay was fixed at ₹2,24,100, leaving him with a higher salary than the senior officer until the latter’s retirement.
The Bench observed that although HAG and HAG-Plus constituted distinct levels in the Pay Matrix, the higher placement was an upgradation granted to one-third of senior officers and was not the result of a separate promotion. Both grades, it said, represented different financial placements within the same military rank.
The Tribunal held that the distinction between HAG and HAG-Plus reflected progression within the same military rank. Treating the two pay levels as wholly unrelated for the limited purpose of examining an admitted pay anomaly between a senior and junior Lieutenant General would, therefore, be artificial.
The Bench also referred to Rule 16 of the Army Officers Pay Rules, 2017, which provides for relaxation of the rules in appropriate cases where their strict application results in undue hardship. The provision, the Tribunal observed, conferred powers to address circumstances requiring such relaxation.
By directing the Army to step up the retired officer’s pay, the AFT emphasised that differences in financial placement within the rank of Lieutenant General cannot automatically be used to deny relief where a senior officer draws less than a junior. The ruling addresses the pay anomaly and its impact on the officer’s retirement benefits, reinforcing the principle that pay-related distinctions must be examined in the context of the officers’ actual military rank and service position.
