The Punjab and Haryana High Court has upheld the 2015 dismissal of former Sapper Harbhal Singh from the Indian Army, rejecting his challenge to the discharge on the ground of prolonged unauthorized absence. A division bench comprising Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi and Justice Mandarjeet Yadav dismissed Singh’s petition, which sought to set aside an Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) order dated April 8, 2026, that had affirmed the Army’s decision.
Singh was enrolled in the Army in March 2002. In November 2011, he proceeded on annual leave that was scheduled to conclude on December 24, 2011. He failed to rejoin his unit after the leave expired and remained continuously absent without authorization for more than four years. The Army declared him a deserter and initiated disciplinary proceedings in 2015. He was dismissed from service on April 20, 2015.
In his petition before the High Court, Singh contended that he had remained mentally unwell for over four years, which prevented his return to duty. He argued that neither the competent Army authorities nor the AFT had adequately considered his circumstances. The High Court, however, found that he had produced no concrete documentary evidence or medical records to substantiate the claim of mental incapacity. The bench held that prolonged unauthorized absence from duty cannot be treated as ordinary absence or overlooked in a disciplined force.
The court referred to a Supreme Court precedent of March 11, 2019, which held that unauthorized absence exceeding 302 days without leave is not condonable in the armed forces, given the high standards of discipline and operational responsibility required. It observed that the Army had followed the applicable rules and prescribed procedure in effecting the dismissal. The High Court further clarified that neither the High Court nor the AFT can function as an appellate authority to re-appreciate evidence or substitute its own view for that of the competent military authority in the absence of procedural irregularity or violation of natural justice.
On these grounds, the petition was dismissed and the dismissal from service was upheld. The ruling reaffirms the principle that members of the armed forces cannot remain absent for extended periods without authorization and later claim reinstatement on unsupported medical grounds, particularly where discipline is foundational to operational effectiveness.
The decision aligns with consistent judicial emphasis on the non-negotiable nature of discipline in the Indian Army, where unauthorized absence for prolonged durations has repeatedly been treated as a grave misconduct warranting dismissal.
