Hyderabad, November 17, 2026: The Telangana High Court has upheld an Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) order granting pensionary benefits to a former Indian Army personnel who was invalided out of service on medical grounds after serving nine years, six months and 15 days. The court held that a marginal shortfall in the minimum qualifying service of 10 years could be condoned, as the discharge was involuntary and the soldier did not leave the service voluntarily.
A Division Bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda dismissed the writ petition filed by the Army authorities challenging the AFT’s March 2022 decision. The High Court passed its order on November 11, 2026. The court emphasised that pension is a benefit earned through service and not a discretionary bounty granted at the pleasure of the State.
Background of the Case
The former soldier was enrolled in the Indian Army in July 2000. In December 2009, a medical board diagnosed him with Alcohol Dependence Syndrome. The Invaliding Medical Board assessed his disability at 11–14 per cent and concluded that the condition was neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service. He was invalided out of service in January 2010 after rendering nine years, six months and 15 days.
On August 18, 2010, the Army authorities confirmed the denial of disability pension on the grounds that the disability was not linked to military service and that the individual fell short of the 10-year qualifying service required for pension. He did not initially appeal the rejection of disability pension but later approached the Armed Forces Tribunal.
AFT and High Court Findings
In March 2022, the AFT held that the former soldier was eligible for pension and related benefits. It condoned the shortfall of approximately one year in qualifying service, noting that the discharge was on medical grounds and not voluntary. The Army challenged this order before the Telangana High Court.
During the hearing, Standing Counsel Arvind Kumar Kata, appearing for the Army, argued that the individual was not entitled to disability pension as the medical board had found the condition neither attributable to nor aggravated by service. He further contended that courts lack medical expertise to interfere with the findings of the medical board. The former soldier was represented by advocate S. Govinda Rao.
The High Court observed that the medical board’s findings on the nature of the disease and its non-attributability to service remained undisturbed. The AFT had not reassessed the medical opinion but had examined the legal consequences of an involuntary medical discharge where the service fell marginally short of the prescribed qualifying period. The bench noted that condoning the limited shortfall was consistent with the purpose of the pension scheme, and no provision expressly barred such condonation when the Army itself had declared the individual medically unfit.
In a key observation, the court stated: “His service ended because the Army found him medically unfit. The shortfall is marginal when compared with the period of 10 years. Pension is not a bounty granted at the pleasure of the State. It is a benefit earned by service.” The court further recorded that courts and tribunals do not possess medical expertise to reassess the Invaliding Medical Board’s findings and should be slow to interfere with them.
The Division Bench dismissed the Army’s petition and upheld the AFT order directing the grant of pension and associated benefits to the former soldier.
This ruling reinforces the principle that soldiers invalided out on medical grounds for reasons not attributable to service may still be entitled to invalid or service pension when the discharge is involuntary and the shortfall in qualifying service is marginal, subject to the applicable pension regulations.
